The Milburn Review has opened a constructive debate on how young people are best served to engage with employment and education.
We'd like to thank the Glasgow Herald for publishing the thoughts of our Principal, Joanna Campbell on this important issue.
Glasgow Herald column 20 November 2026:
"Colleges take young people from a life of welfare to a life of work"
The headlines generated by the publication, earlier this week, of Alan Milburn's report into Britain's one million Neets (under-25s not in education, employment or training) are both predictable and understandable.
The focus has been, on one hand, on whether or not Mr Milburn's proposals will reduce the size of the welfare bill, which is expanding rapidly and is a concern across the political spectrum.
On the other hand, discussion has turned to the social impact and the moral questionability of the existing system which, in Mr Milburn's view, discourages work and encourages welfare amongst young people who are fit to work.
Those discussions will continue.
However, while they do, we must expand our focus on the bridges which will take young people from a life of welfare to a life of work.
That is where we, in the college sector, come in.
At Glasgow Kelvin College, we see tackling youth disengagement as being about much more than education.
We create clear, supportive pathways that connect young people with confidence, skills, qualifications and ultimately sustainable employment.
That is harder than it sounds.
More than two in every five of our students at Glasgow Kelvin are from Scotland's 10% most deprived postcodes.
This is well in excess of the Scottish college average.
Not all 'Neets' are from deprived backgrounds, but those that are will be the hardest to reach and the hardest to shift from often generational unemployment to securing skills and qualifications that open routes to work and further learning.
This gets to the heart of the most important focus of the Milburn review – opportunity.
We see every day that talent is spread evenly across society, but opportunity is not.
Our job is to close that gap, and only by closing that gap will this national endeavour be successful.
To a large degree, colleges across Britain, like Glasgow Kelvin, are already doing what Mr Milburn's report wants us to do.
I can, with absolute certainty, say that if it were not for colleges, the number of Neets would already be much larger.
Of course, employers and universities also have an important role to play, but colleges are absolutely central and their role requires acknowledged levels of investment in order to deliver on a local and national basis.
In Scotland, if we consider the nation's growth industries – renewables, food and drink, hospitality, health care, digital, construction and so on – we can quickly see that the college sector is vital to our economic growth and to the prospect of good, enduring employment for our young people.
A recent economic impact study showed that for every £1 invested in Glasgow Kelvin College, we provide a £7 return.
The question then becomes: if we want colleges to offer young people a route into work rather than a life on welfare, how do we protect and enhance the sector?
We can start by acknowledging that many young people don't need a university-style pathway.
It was not so long ago that those of us involved in tertiary education could not say that out loud, but that is no longer the case.
Politicians, parents, employers and young people themselves are all beginning to ask whether the presumption that university is a superior choice is wise.
Governments north and south of the border which have pushed this approach throughout this century have been well meaning, and it remains the case that a young person from any social background, with a particular academic ambition, should be able to realise it.
However, we must now evolve out of a presumption that college is an inferior choice.
It is not.
Different, yes.
Inferior, no.
Indeed, young people who come to us after secondary education find themselves, a few years later, in a job paying a higher salary than many of their peers who choose the university path, with enduring prospects and applying relevant skills.
This phenomenon is particularly prevalent here in Glasgow.
Half of Glasgow's young people are educated to degree level, and yet we also have amongst the highest percentages of Neets.
We have the ability to create a national parity between vocational and technical education and academic education, but not without a clearer national focus on the social and economic benefits of colleges.
We have unmet demand, constantly accentuated by a college funding system which reflects neither that increased demand nor the economic need on which it is based.
To get the right output, we need the right input.
We need sustainable and flexible funding based on national missions, the ability to plan more than 12 months at a time, and recognition that funding sits across a number of government areas including justice, health and the economy – not just education.
Tackling the Neets problem requires a whole-system approach involving schools, colleges, employers, local authorities and community organisations, as well as politicians, of course.
No single organisation can solve this on its own.
But the mission of Glasgow Kelvin College is to transform lives through education, and that places us right in the middle of everything Mr Milburn has proposed this week.
Joanna Campbell, Principal & CEO